Definition of New Members

Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Diver300

Well-Known Member
Most Helpful Member
We sometimes see old threads that haven't had any activity for years, and then someone replies. Looking at the site description of the OP on the posting, it often has "New Member". I assume that it because the OP has only posted a few times, but the description is a bit misleading when the OP has joined a decade ago, and maybe hasn't been seen for years either.

Would it be a good idea to change the description, or put in slightly different information?
 
Or just look at the date of the first post in the thread.

Then you can avoid replying to a long dead thread which has been re-animated by a mis guided first time poster or maybe a plain and simple spammer.

JimB
 
Maybe create a new category of "stale members", but there is no reason to over complicate it. "Spammer removed" to all thread members would be cool and re-dating the thread to the right last post would probably be the BEST way.
 
I believe Vilfredo Pareto would be proud to see that his 20/80 rule is still very valid in this and other web forums.

Although I think the ratio here could be higher: 10/90 or even perhaps 5/95.

Some %5 of all users make 95% of the posts.
If I were a moderator, with access to the forum's statistical data, I would run some statistics to determine the exact Pareto ratio.
 
schmitt trigger said:
If I were a moderator, with access to the forum's statistical data, I would run some statistics to determine the exact Pareto ratio.
Click to expand...
Far like too much work.... Admin can do that.... Web pages is NOT my fortè
 
Ian Rogers said:
On AAC there is a warning displaying "Old thread" before you post...
Click to expand...
...which is routinely ignored by clueless newbies.

My own preference would be to automatically lock any thread which has been inactive for more than 6 months or so, but that's just me. Not sure there's any way to do that, anyhow.
 
OBW0549 said:
...which is routinely ignored by clueless newbies.

My own preference would be to automatically lock any thread which has been inactive for more than 6 months or so, but that's just me. Not sure there's any way to do that, anyhow.
Click to expand...
Then new users who come just because of that old thread they found on google are forced to make new threads about the same things and the old members then start yelling at them that's its a duplicate from another thread and to use the search function...

Absolutely nothing wrong with raising a thread from the dead if you have something to contribute for the future readers.
 
narkeleptk said:
Absolutely nothing wrong with raising a thread from the dead if you have something to contribute for the future readers.
Click to expand...
That's true, but in a lot of cases, most-likely many more than we regular members get to witness, dead threads get necro'd without actually adding anything positive...
...an example from yesterday:

Help for PWM control with TL494 (KA7500) for 12/24V

Hello all! I need a project or schematics for PWM control for max 30A to 12/24V. Thanks for your cooperation.
www.electro-tech-online.com
 
I see nothing wrong with that example. Its good advice for any future readers. If you don't want to contribute to it then don't and it will drop in to obscurity again until the next lurker picks it up on google only this time it has an a small answer to go with it. Just because the original poster is mia doesn't mean others who are interested in the topic are.
 
The reply to the OP, roughly 9 years later, amounted to little more than RTFM....
 
I agree that some posts should stay, but the majority are exactly what Mick said... "Can you supply to me all you did because I'm too lazy" kinda post...
 
We should be able to easily prevent new members from posting to a thread more than 3-months old.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

"Last seen" date not updating on all members?
Replies
5
Views
5K
Nigel Goodwin
New record for blocked popups/ads!
Replies
6
Views
16K
Pommie
P
F
When not logged in, new post titles display vertically
Replies
0
Views
41K
fourtytwo
F
Lot's of 500 errors and others.
Replies
2
Views
3K
Nigel Goodwin
Adding new posts from within the 'Articles' section, to the 'Latest posts' section?
Replies
0
Views
3K
Mickster
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…