No, it's a good idea, and exactly what I think that will be is now underway in EU and USA.
Sure, it's not there yet, but lawmakers are fighting to push this law as people are expecting.
There will be a harsh fight with a manufacturers, though.
I agree, surely it will raise prices, but it would pay off in a long run, since you will not spend on buying new device every two years.
They would just have to provide spares, not service.
EU proposed law that will demand components (IC's, transistors...).
Providing spares is
VERY expensive - going back a good many years there was legislation that manufacturers had to keep spares for seven years - and the costs of that go on the price of the equipment. Sharp Electronics got round it by pricing CRT's (and later LCD's), which take considerable expensive space to store, at considerably more than the price of the TV, and not allowing service agents to replace them under warranty. I even had a Sharp 25 inch CRT TV, and as a matter of interest I priced a CRT for it - the sets retailed for about £399 - a replacement CRT was £1500+VAT at trade.
This meant they never sold any, so only had to keep a couple in stock, and after seven years they just crushed them - I happened to be there on a course one day, and they had a special skip with a built-in crusher, crushing all the CRT's for disposal.
Presumably you, as well as the EU, don't have the slightest idea of how the electronics industry works? - a manufacturer (such as Sony, or
TESCO'S - who are also a 'manufacturer') - order X thousand TV's from the factory, and also order whatever spares they think will be needed over the life of the set. The factory run the production line to create the required number of sets and spares, then the production line is shut down, and reconfigured to make something else. These are all the sets and spares that will ever exist - the factory don't have any spares, they are just a manufacturing facility for a third party.
So obviously Tesco's have a huge spares and facility, where all the spares are kept and service carried out? - I don't think so
You should also bear in mind the manufcaturing life of the chips used, most of those will only have a manufacturing life of a year or two (if you're lucky) so who keeps all those spares?.