Hi there,
For many circuits like this one the input is not always referenced to ground, but to the 'null' point, which is 2.5v. That means the output will be much less than we might think at first. For example, with 0v input we should get roughly 0v output, with a little offset because there is only one offset adjustment.
In other words, if the gain of both stages was 1 we would get plus and minus 1v peak for plus and minus 1v input peaks. Since the total gain is around 7.29, that means we would get 0.729v peak output for a 0.1v peak input. For 0.2v peak input, twice that. This is again referenced to the null point.
Keep in mind however that the LM358 may clip at Vcc-1.5v though, so for a 5v supply and 2.5v null that means we only get about a volt headroom for going postive, meaning the output can only go up to about 1v peak (referenced to the null point of 2.5v again). That limits the input to around 0.13v peak (again referenced to the 2.5v null point).
For simulation though the input sine should be referenced to the 2.5v null point also, at least for most circuits like this.