Resonance and dB

Status
Not open for further replies.
audioguru said:
An LC filter would be big and also needs its frequency to be tuned. How?
Click to expand...
It itsn't hard to calculate the nurber of turns on a suitable core and it doesn't have to spot on. Huge 100kW transmitters have filters so I don't see how a little 400W unit is hard to produce.

A lowpass filter won't work well.
Click to expand...
Class C audio amplifiers seem to do alright.

Maybe a series resonant circuit in series with the speaker?
Click to expand...
What about the huge voltages that would develop across the capaciitor and inductor?
 
I'm ok with buying parts, guys.

What should i buy that would give me a crap load of power? Remember, i only know how to use NPN, PNP, and POWER transisors/regulators.
 
Hi Hero,
We are talking about making 1.6kHz, not 1MHz. The filter's inductor and capacitor will be huge and will need to be tuned.

Hi Marks,
Plug your speaker into 120VAC from the mains if you want to destroy it. There is a 1.6kW amplifier making the rounds on this site. You will need about 20 of them to feed hundreds of ordinary speakers to make enough sound pressure to break a little glass.
 
audioguru said:
Hi Hero,
We are talking about making 1.6kHz, not 1MHz. The filter's inductor and capacitor will be huge and will need to be tuned.
Click to expand...
A 1.6kHz coil designed for a small 400W inverter (because that's what it is) will still be much smaller than a 1MHz coil used in a huge 100kW AM transmitter, it'll sill be much smaller than a 400W mains transformer.

Tuned?
I don't think so, you only need to filter out the higher frequency harmonics.
 
An LC lowpass filter won't filter out very well the very strong 3rd harmonic from the square-wave. A tuned circuit would be an excellent filter because it could have a high Q.
 
audioguru said:
An LC lowpass filter won't filter out very well the very strong 3rd harmonic from the square-wave.
Click to expand...
Class D audio amps have them and they don't seem to have any problems.
 
Hero999 said:
Class D audio amps have them and they don't seem to have any problems.
Click to expand...
If a class-D audio amp had its switching frequency at only 4.8kHz like this circuit would have its 3rd harmonic then the loud whistle would drive you crazy. They switch at hundreds of kHz so their LC lowpass filter is very effective.
 
PA systems at stadiums need to project sound far and use very high sound pressure levels to travel far. They have a horn to focus the sound and make the speaker very efficient. They can produce 132dB at 1m at frequencies above 800Hz. They are fairly expensive compared to ordinary speakers.
 

Attachments

  • PA horn speaker.JPG
    40.6 KB · Views: 409
A horn is a mechanical transformer, it matches the imedance of the speaker to the impedance of the air (both MECHANICAL impedance, not electrical) - this gives MUCH greater efficiency - quite possibly between 5 and 10 times more than a conventional speaker. The drawback is much greater complaxity and size!.
 
audioguru said:
If a class-D audio amp had its switching frequency at only 4.8kHz like this circuit would have its 3rd harmonic then the loud whistle would drive you crazy. They switch at hundreds of kHz so their LC lowpass filter is very effective.
Click to expand...
The sound will already drive you crazy. Providing most of the power is at the frequency you need then it simply doesn't matter. I challange you to prove to me that an ineffieient class AB design will provide an over all greater efficiency than an h-bridge connected to a low pass filter. Yes I know an h-birdge will waste power in unwanted harmonics but no way near as much power as the class ab system will waste in heat.

You don't really need fidelity here so a high powered PA or siren speaker will do.
 
Hi Hero,
Transistors in an inefficient but distortion-free amplifier can be cooled with heatsinks, speakers that are also being heated with unwanted harmonics cannot.
The harmonics of a square-wave have the same amount of power as the fundamental sine-wave frequency when they have the same p-p voltage.

If the inductor is low loss, a 2nd order Butterworth LC filter would reduce the power of the fundamental sine-wave to half (-3dB) the total output power, and will reduce the power of the harmonics to about 1/4 (-6dB) of the fundamental's power. Therefore more speakers, h-bridge drivers and LC filters would be needed to produce max sound pressure at a single frequency, when compared to a sine-wave signal.
 
How about building a low quality class-D amplifier, it's a more complex circuit but will probably work out cheaper because the transformer and heatsinks are a the most expensive parts?
 
Funnily enough, I was watching a repeat of 'Brainiacs' on TV yesterday, it's one a I saw a year or two back - and they tried the glass breaking trick.

Initially they tried an opera singer, who determined the glass resonated at C#, but was unable to break it. They then tried the rock band Status Quo, who also determined it was C# - they continually played the note on their guitars, through a BIG stack of Marshall cabs - and after about 10 seconds or so the glass smashed to pieces!

So you need an accurate note, VERY high power, and keep it going until the glass breaks!.
 
Last edited:
Nigel Goodwin said:
Funnily enough, I was watching a repeat of 'Brainiacs' on TV yesterday, it's one a I saw a year or too back - and they tried the glass breaking trick.
Click to expand...

Nigel, i am not one to hold a grudge, but you spelt "two" wrong.... Lol.


Anyways, i know for a fact that i have a VERY accurate tone generator, i have all the time in the world, but i am not sure about finding enough power.... Oh well, were there is a will there is a way.....
 
Marks256 said:
Nigel, i am not one to hold a grudge, but you spelt "two" wrong.... Lol.
Click to expand...

Not any more!

Anyways, i know for a fact that i have a VERY accurate tone generator, i have all the time in the world, but i am not sure about finding enough power.... Oh well, were there is a will there is a way.....
Click to expand...

The frequency isn't the problem, just the power - get yourself a big heap of 4x12's and a couple of thousand watts!.
 
For effectiveness, a single tone may not be the answer, just about any physical object has different harmonics in more than one dimension, and even if the core resonance of the object is known that might not be the best frequency to hit it with, unless it's a tuneing fork shaped glass... Considering the actual amount of power delivered to an object is related to frequency you may want to use a frequency several harmonics above the objects resonant frequency, perhaps two speakers at the same distance from the object on opposite sides, one being fed it's signal through a basic inverting amplifier (doubling the effective delivered energy) If both speakers are generating the base frequency plus a few odd harmonics at resonance you might get some results.
 
Haven't you wet your fingers then gently rubbed around the top of a crystal galss to make it ring? The sound is a pure sine-wave without harmonics. That sound is needed very loud to break the glass.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

P
Just watching "While the rest of us die" and it's very interesting. However,
Replies
15
Views
9K
Kerim
S
How do I minimize/prevent AND recover from burnout from studying?
Replies
14
Views
4K
shivajikobardan
S
S
How do I motivate myself to study with 100% focus and concentration during covid lockdown?
Replies
5
Views
3K
tvrgeek
T
Post COVID19 and Free Masons.
Replies
4
Views
3K
killivolt
V
Statler and Waldorf in Residence?
Replies
1
Views
2K
Pommie
P
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…