Resistors can run over 100C easily, even more, with no damage to them. Some are rated for close to 200C actually.
Changing to 5W may not change the thermal image, it will still dissipate the same heat, and eventually become just as hot.
Bottom line, resistors are designed to run hot and as long as the resistor wattage rating is not exceeded, you should be ok. I have one device where I limit the current via a pair of 10W resistors (20W total dissipation) that dissipate about 3W total, and they run up to 102C. I had a pair of 5W as well, (identical ohms) and they also ran at around 102C, maybe a little bit more... So, changing to higher wattage resistors did not make much difference. Final temperature depends on how well the resistors can dissipate the heat. Higher wattage resistors still dissipate the same heat (in general), their rating is only a maximum wattage they can handle, not the maximum heat generated.