As i said, the new design is tried and tested and working much much better. and really is the simple way of doing it, opamps tend to act a little different in real situations and funny enough not very well for mine. The final design of the opamp version was moderated and accepted as the "way to do it", with your schematics and all the others incorporated correctly. But in this case i have found the simple full wave rectifier to work much better. Because it works you see.