I have watched the 1953 version, 1960 version, the other 2005 version, this 2005 version and read the book. I have also heard the Jeff waynes soundtrack, the Dance remix of that sound track and the 2005 sound track. I would most definately rate this as the best WOTW movie i have ever seen and probably one of the greatest pieces of entertainment i have seen for a few years.
I watched it on the big screen cause i wanted the full effect. But, I can understand why people would watch a downloaded version though, 9/10 times Hollywood sux and Cinemas are allways a rippoff.