I am not fully following why the circuit will not work with single Q.
The lamp will turn on and stay on via the be junction (and of course the 33Ohm resistor). why would it just flash once?
Assuming the current you calculated into D+ is ~3.5A, the base current would have to be 3.5/(hfe+1)
which is roughly 318mA. (assuming hfe = 10). I am not sure if your lamp would draw that amount of current on VB - 0.6V-D+ ?
But you have a point in that this could settle at a base current that is not enough for the lamp to be visibly glowing. D+ could rise enough so that the lamp current is too low to be visible.
Perhaps one could see a flash, initially but probably not as the transistor is too fast and D+ would rise very quickly.
The lamp will turn on and stay on via the be junction (and of course the 33Ohm resistor). why would it just flash once?
Assuming the current you calculated into D+ is ~3.5A, the base current would have to be 3.5/(hfe+1)
which is roughly 318mA. (assuming hfe = 10). I am not sure if your lamp would draw that amount of current on VB - 0.6V-D+ ?
But you have a point in that this could settle at a base current that is not enough for the lamp to be visibly glowing. D+ could rise enough so that the lamp current is too low to be visible.
Perhaps one could see a flash, initially but probably not as the transistor is too fast and D+ would rise very quickly.
Last edited: