Torben
Well-Known Member
First off, if we're talking about the robot that's torturing the other robots, that guy has the coolest voice of all the Star Wars robots! Second, the mechanical moving with respect to his voice reflects what I believe are two essential components to a great movie robot: 1) how the robot works should be within the scope of being believable; 2) some element of the robot should be beyond the scope of being believable, as to provoke the imagination. Getting the mix just right is the key I think, especially with respect to the last point.
I see where you're coming from on points 1 and 2 but in my opinion that particular robot wildly missed the mark on both counts, especially point 2. Even as a kid I thought the useless flapping metal jaw was stupid. It's not so much unbelievable as just pointless.
As far as the incidental robots from that series go, I had nightmares (some of the worst of my childhood) about the medical droid from Empire Strikes Back, when Luke is in the biogel tank. I don't know why that one freaked me out so much.
Torben