The LM358 is not an audio opamp, instead it has low power. Therefore it has a lot of noise, produces crossover distortion and has trouble with high audio frequencies.
If the actor says, "She sells seashells on the seashore" then the LED will show, "Rumble hissss, Ee ell ee ell on uh ee or, rumble hissss" (vowels only, no consonants). Maybe a little exaggerated, but I am an audio guy and I hate the LM324 and LM358.