We do speak US in the UK too.Perhaps you may not be aware but on this side of the pond the term "Super" is often used to denote "big quantity" which may not make a whole lot of sense to our friends in UK ( hey, I have British relatives)----but sorry I did not start the term
... they are really exceptionally unreliable-
I'd have to disagree with that sentence;
Granted it may be unreliable in Consumer Electronics which is mostly based on design issue and not critical. (Although countless number of them were used throughout the product cycle).
When designed properly, lifetime hours are not that far from the respective datasheets. There are many factors involved with several reports by likes of Yamaha, Panasonic ELNA and Mitsumi
Speaking of reliability, in Aviation, Airbus 380 has been using super capacitors for some time (Emergency evacuation sliders). Wonder how reliable is that![]()
My opinion, for what it is worth, is that you are both right.
When super capacitors first came out they were fussy, unreliable things that needed to be treated with kid gloves, and some versions were better than others. But, the technology has matured and you can get reliable supercaps now, but you obviously need to take note of the data sheet- the net is full of dubious circuits using supercaps. This also applies to LiIon batteries.
Just like LiIon batteries, if you stick with good makes you will have fewer problems.
spec