I was always taught to use the 10% to 90%, not 0 to 100%
Hello there,
Well, you will notice i used the word 'approximately' in the first reply that talked about this.
That's because for one i wanted to keep it simple, but really it doesnt matter if you use 0 to 100 or 10 to 90 percent when calculating the slew rate for a perfect ramp. You can use 0 to 100, 10 to 90, 20 to 80, or even 10 to 20 percent. As long as you use the time period between those two states and also the voltage levels of those two states.
Rise times are sometimes defined differently depending on the application or what is being measured or what information we are looking for.
For example, for a ramp that goes from 0 to 100 percent over a voltage of 0 to 10 volts and it takes 10us, then to go from 0 to 50 percent it changes by only 5 volts and that only takes 5us. So if you calculate using 0 to 100 percent you get 10v/10us and if you calculate using 0 to 50 percent you get 5v/5us, either of which results in a slew rate of 1v/us.
So i tried to keep it simple and approximate by using the description of "bottom to top" or even "top to bottom".
What happens in real life however is much more complicated because the wave may not be a perfect ramp. In that case you would want to find the max slew rate which would be the place where it changes the fastest. That might be from 40 percent to 60 percent for example.
So rather than call it "rise time" even though that is accurate, we should probably just call it the "time it takes to rise" (from one level to another). This way we leave the more common convention alone.
One thing we dont want to do though is make the mistake of using the full voltage change while using only something like the 10 and 90 percent rule. In that case we might measure a time that is shorter than what we really needed. So if the wave changes from 0 to 10v where 0 is min and 10v is max 100 percent and we use the 10 and 90 percent rule, then we would be using a time value that is too short because the voltage only changed by 8 volts between those two limits.