Sorry 200mV and 125mV is wrong I was able to get about 1V tops. Well anyway I re-did the test with a sweep(20hz-2khz) and I noticed it the amplitude started high at about 200mV(because the volume was not at max) and I saw it notch down to about 51 or 59mV(cannot remember exactly but it's close enough for the explaination) and it started to pick back up as expected. Well, I figured the frequency of the notch with my scope and the center was about 460hz well, I had about a few secs for it to go from the notch amplitude and rise which means that it probly had a notch stretch at the same amplitude for maybe 430 - 460hz is what I assume from what I recall. 460 was actually around the high side.
But anyway, my smart self forgot to use a 2M load! Can I go from output to gnd with a 2m resistor?
EDIT: I just aded 2M of resistance from output to GND and I got a notch at about 335hz.
EDIT: Dang for some reason I forgot the GND connection to the opamp...It's strange how it still gave a notch or even output? After adding the GND to the pin, I get a distorted waveform so i'm not sure what's wrong. I used polarised capacitors for the power supply, electrolytic. Is that bad?