Hi,
Few basic question again-
- Will it stop the charging process if battery charged fully? No chance to over charge? (I think yes)
- What is the chance of explode battery during charging, if battery is internally shorted? Will the circuit protect or will the circuit stop the current instantly?
- May be I can apply general purposes any NPN like BC547B there, isn't it? (but also I have 5 pieces of 2N4401 sent by Charles)
Thaks!
Hello again,
The circuit charges the battery with the usual Li-ion charge profile where the current starts out at the max and then when the voltage gets very close to the set point the current starts to taper off until it reaches a very very low level. For all practical purposes, the cell does not overcharge when the voltage set point is set correctly.
We have to be careful when reading some other web sites because they assume certain things and make conclusions based on those assumptions. If you remove even one of the assumptions, then you invalidate the conclusions. If the voltage is set to 4.15v then the cell can never overcharge because the voltage has to reach something like 4.25v before it begins to overcharge.
Also, stating that the cell can not absorb overcharge is not that informative of a statement in all cases. Yes it is true that it can not absorb overcharge and this is a reference to a comparison with other types of cells that can like NiCd. But what we want to know is not just whether or not it can absorb overcharge (which we know it can not) but also what conditions can cause an overcharge. We need to examine these conditions and how they relate to our charge circuit to know if the cell can overcharge.
So we know that comparing these cells to other cells that they are less flexible during the charge phase, but we also need to know the limits of that flexibility or else we'll call every charger out there 'bad' for the cell.
Commercial chargers turn off after the current reaches a low level related to the maximum current level. This is to protect their own but also because they often attempt a higher termination voltage. We could build this into the charger too, but it would be a waste of time and energy.
That said, a good set point for the charge termination voltage is 4.15 volts not 4.20 volts. What this does is it sets the maximum voltage for the cell at 4.15 volts, meaning that if you connect a cell that is 4.2 volts to the circuit it will probably actually DISCHARGE. Also, the slightly less voltage makes up for any meter inaccuracies, but you should use the best meter you can find to set this voltage, and check it often.
The drawback to using 4.15 volts is that the cell capacity is slightly reduced for that charge cycle, but it's not enough to worry about. The good thing is that the cell has a longer life and runs safer.
For a cell that has been discharged too low however it is a different story. Low cell voltage could cause an 'almost but not quite yet' short internal to the battery which may not show itself until the voltage across that 'almost short' increases. That's when the current jumps the now closer gap and causes a high current discharge which causes rapid and intense heat buildup which causes fire, smoke, and loud sound. So the only way to test if there is a short is to charge the cell and wait for fire, smoke, and loud sound <chuckle>. That's why you cant charge a cell that has been discharged too low. Of course it is entirely possible that this 'almost short' did not form yet, and then the cell can work fine for years to come. But it is that risk that is what tells us not to do it. It is also possible that there is a delay between the time we charge and the time we see fire and smoke. That delay would be caused by an 'almost short' that was less than that required to cause current to flow immediately but then happens at a later time just the same. Normal everyday mechanical stress applied to the outside of the package could cause that 'almost short' gap to become closer, thus initiating a sudden and intense high current discharge. This also tells us something about the proper everyday handling of the cells even when not charging them.
As for a cell having an internal short, if that happens all bets are off. It doesnt matter if it is being charged or not. If it shorts inside it could cause an explosion depending on how much energy there is left in the cell.
A good idea is to charge the cell inside a metal container of some type maybe with an open top so that the pressure cant build up inside.
I will also add that this charge methodology is based on leaving the cell on charge for 24 hours or less but it's best to never leave the cell alone when it is being charged no matter what charger you use.